trainingreality helping people work better with people
win-win situation
Please press (at least!) one of these.
It costs you nothing, and (possibly) helps us spread the word!

Why "Win-Win" doesn't win with me

Thursday, 17 February 2011

"Win-win". Or, for the even trendier (worse) out there, "win-win-win". It's a real struggle for me to be even remotely positive about this cliché, but I'm going to try...

"Win-win" generally applies to you (or your organisation) winning - being pleased with a result - and your client or customer winning - again, being pleased with the end result. It's the happy-clappy antidote to the nasty old capitalist free market win-lose game that dreadful people played in the 1980's: companies screwing their customers, customers screwing their suppliers; anything went as long as we got the biggest slice of the pie.

"Win-win-win" usually adds "stakeholders" into the equation, but that's so annoying it must be a subject for a future article on its own.

Then, a small but brilliant cadre of gurus (along with anyone with any common sense or anyone who had ever worked in the real world, so not many people really) saw that there was another way, and that it was beautiful. Why should we not try to reach an arrangement where both "sides" are happy with the outcome? That way, we might be able to do business with them more than once! Superb!

Obviously, there is not a lot wrong with the underlying idea here; the problem, as usual, is just how glibly the phrase is used, and how little real understanding exists when people talk about other groups or organisations "winning" alongside them.

There are two great advantages to ensuring that you take other people's interests into account when making decisions:

Relationship longevity

As a child, growing up with my younger sister, we had a very simple rule enforced upon us about how food was shared. One person cut the food into portions, and the other got to select which portion they ate. Very quickly - we were smart children! - we worked out that a 50/50 split was the only way to go (unless there were differences in who liked what, or earlier/later negotiations coming into play, but that simply complicates the matter). If one of us both cut and chose, we might have a "win-lose", but it would only last until the roles were reversed...and then...

As grown-ups, I hope we really don't need those rules any more. If we respect our customers and suppliers, and ensure that we don't screw them when we work with them, we'll have a much longer relationship, which can lead to wonderful things.

Two heads are better than one

By developing these long-term relationships with our customers and suppliers, we can also improve the future ("grow the pie", to use another all-prevalent cliché) for both of us. Our customers can tell us what they like and we can provide it for them; our suppliers can learn what we need, and provide it for us. Not only does "win-win" mean that we are both happy with an individual transaction: it means that we will continue to do business, and do more and better business as the relationship develops.


To raise "win-win" from the realms of cheesy cliché into something more meaningful, we need to really mean it. We need to have an inbuilt understanding that
  • our relationships are going to be long-term;
  • that we operate in a way that is suitable for us both;
  • that there is no significant power imbalance between us; and
  • we must invest time and effort in building those relationships.

Still, I'd prefer it if everyone would just pack in using this phrase completely and find better ways of explaining what they're actually trying to do!

Please press (at least!) one of these.
It costs you nothing, and (possibly) helps us spread the word!
Please leave your thoughts and comments here

There are 10 comments
gravatar xxewe
September 02, 2016 - 16:10

New iPhone 8 I hope you will keep writing articles as good as this, so I gained extensive insight ... thanks.

gravatar engineering thermodynamics by p.k.nag pdf
July 30, 2016 - 14:45
gravatar ylxtp1314
July 27, 2016 - 07:12

Having all the brands at one place would provide you an opportunity to compare the quality, design and features of accessories of different makes. Also it would help you compare their prices. Handbag wholesalers can help you locate the bag you are dreaming about at your price.You can hermes replica expect lucrative discount on bestselling bags from big retailers. Web stores can give discounts because they save money on physical facilities, sales staff and equipments.Every woman keeps several bags like a large carrier for vacations, clutch for daily use and purse for keeping very personal belongings. Fashion accessories come in different shapes, sizes and colors to suit individual needs. Fashion conscious women look for accessories that can be doubled as a fashion gear hermes replica handbags as well as a carrier. Only handbag wholesalers can provide you full range of ladies carriers as they keep products from each brand to give their customers a wide choice.Shopping is a matter of choice. Women like to shop,where they get largest range and a wide choice. If you are looking for a beautiful bag then look no further than handbag wholesalers because these shops can give many options. Visit the online store that has products from all the leading and upcoming brands so that you can choose the right product.

gravatar raleigh simon – San Jose,CA
February 09, 2016 - 06:56

This is a very useful post, thank you! I agree that innovations are the most important thing for most businesses, because with today鈥檚 fast changing world we need to stay on top of the changes, if we want to survive.
Essay Writing Service ReviewsEssay Writing Service Reviews

gravatar kajal
December 28, 2015 - 10:14
Subject: msp vip

Click this given link msp hack vip diamonds starcoins and generate free diamonds and star coins for the free msp vip account.

gravatar Lina Rose
December 11, 2015 - 11:48
Subject: Awesome

Hi everyone. I know you did really well work. About your new recipe just i say its really yummy. I love your all hard made food. Please update some more recipes. Gymnastic Mats for sale in Low Price from our website

gravatar new year 2016
August 27, 2015 - 11:54

I am thankful for the article.Really looking forward to read year 2016 happy new year 2016 bonne ann茅e 2016 feliz a帽o 2016

gravatar Jack
March 13, 2015 - 21:13
Subject: edu

Formal Education plays pivotal role in the development of custom essay writing service uk. It educates a person regarding their responsibilities towards the other members of the society. IT creates sense to share and transfer the positive values, abilities, activities and habits with other individuals.

gravatar oakley sunglasses
September 03, 2014 - 05:14
gravatar Whitney
July 21, 2013 - 02:46
Subject: Win-win situations - management clich閟 and jargon. Management training blog from Simon Roskrow

I'm gone to tell my little brother, that he should also visit this weblog on regular basis to obtain updated from most recent news update.

Leave a Comment

? ?

Powered by TalkBack